But the church’s evangelicals gained new allies with the dramatic rise over the last twenty-five years of United Methodism in Africa, where nearly half and perhaps more of the church’s 12.5 million membership now live. Mark Tooley is the President of the Institute on Religion and Democracy. United Methodists' Anti-LGBTQ Actions Could Create Schism The decision by United Methodists to reaffirm a traditional stand on homosexuality and marriage leaves the church's future unclear. There are two distinct coalitions within the United Methodist Church, an evangelical-international coalition and a progressive-centrist coalition. Why, you may ask, was that of importance to Episcopalians? Once coronavirus subsides and it reopens, I plan on becoming active there. The attempt to … But increasing polarization and acrimony, culminating in a contentious special General Conference focused on sexuality last year, have made staying together impossible. United Methodist Insight welcomes submissions from our readers and followers. The new traditional church also would receive $25 million from the old liberalized denomination. Unity and Schism Plans for the United Methodist Church [list] Visions from the Bottom-Up. A new plan has been proposed since then to … Photo by Nick Judin. Tuesday, January 7, 2020. If a proposed schism … With many others, I hoped my denomination could avoid schism. Hillary Levin/ASSOCIATED PRESS United Methodist Church delegates from Illinois participate in a day of prayer in St. Louis on Feb. 23, ... For years, the UMC has been grappling with the possibility of a schism over whether to welcome queer Christians. Vance Rains is an outspoken ally of his LGBTQ worshipers. There would also be smaller funding for potentially additional new denominations, which might include a radical liberationist Methodism impatient with conventionally liberal United Methodism. The debate may cripple and perhaps ultimately kill many divided local churches. Many Methodists who have not followed national church news will be caught by surprise when their local church finally has this difficult conversation. United Methodist Church Faces Schism Over Same-Sex Marriage Doctrine Religion News Service Religion News Service Stephen Mallett, of Nashville, Tenn., listens during a news conference announcing a case against Rev. Progressive members of the church are in favor of ordaining queer clergy and allowing Methodist ministers to officiate at same-sex … United Methodism avoided schism for decades by avoiding hard debates at the local church level and proclaiming a false unity. The new traditionalist Methodist denomination likely will end up with larger membership than the old liberal United Methodism. Editor’s Note: The following essay appears in the Spring 2020 issue of Eikon. LGBT Issues: What The United Methodist Church Will Do To Resolve Schism. There is no need for acrimony or looking back. Liberals would inherit the church’s name and US-based bureaucracy. In effect, what remains of The United Methodist Church after the schism, under this “protocol,” could deliver more than $50,000,000 to new Methodist denominations that … These conventions of up to one thousand delegates meet for approximately ten days every four years to set denominational policy. RELATED: United Methodist Church postpones General Conference amid coronavirus. Meanwhile, old United Methodism will be almost totally comprised of US members, with 3.5 or four million, a number that will quickly shrink further, following the example of other denominations that liberalized on sexuality. In effect, what remains of The United Methodist Church after the schism, under this “protocol,” could deliver more than $50,000,000 to new Methodist denominations that might continue advocating discrimination on the basis of human sexuality without having to define the theological, ethical, or moral basis on which it will deny the “sacred worth” of all persons. There are nine United Methodist Churches within approximately four miles of the campus. They say they’re fighting for minorities, but really they’re doing what privileged liberal whites have always done in America – being racist. The United Methodist Church is one of the few places in American life where people as different as Hillary Clinton and Jeff Sessions can share the same pew. Later in 2019, liberal and conservative church caucus groups convened to negotiate a denominational division. … Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our, United Methodist Church postpones General Conference amid coronavirus, Why United Methodist Church’s plan for separation is good for everyone, Providence: A Journal of Christianity & American Foreign Policy. The US church bureaucracy has been liberal for many decades, and few conservatives are interested in trying to reform it. Local United Methodist Churches Face Schism Over LGBTQ Inclusion. Some already know which course their congregation likely will adopt; others will have to wait for events to unfold. In January 2020, this mediation announced agreement on a Protocol of Reconciliation and Grace Through Separation, which would divide United Methodism. An … (Mark Tooley is president of the Institute on Religion and Democracy and editor of Providence: A Journal of Christianity & American Foreign Policy. This frankness followed by division will be wrenching for many. When United Methodism does get to vote to divide into conservative and liberal denominations, thousands of congregations and millions of church members will face difficult choices. Some, like me, will make their choices before then. After fifty years of fractious debate over sexuality, The United Methodist Church is about to divide into two or more denominations. It’s more productive to look forward to a better Methodist future without endless battles. United Methodist approach: Retain inequality while continuing debate, and live with the resultant tension and division. A group of theologically progressive United Methodists and others have formed a new denomination in advance of an expected schism within the United Methodist Church over LGBT issues. For half a century, the United Methodist Church has debated the full inclusion of its LGBTQ members. US United Methodism loses nearly one hundred thousand members annually, while Africa sometimes gains twice that number every year. They will have the chance to shape a new global denomination with classic Methodist theology. But when the culture shifted, the church’s moderates followed. St. Louis helped persuade US liberals that even if history is on their side, church demography is not. But when the pastor earlier this year preached a sermon in which he disagreed with traditional church teaching on sexuality, I realized I could no longer stay. All of us, traditionalists and progressives, can model how to respect each other even as we divide. CBMW Executive Office Story by Nick Judin. The schism plan most likely to be approved would ask Methodist congregations to decide by majority vote whether to join a new traditional denomination or stick with a liberal United Methodism that allows same-sex couples to be married in the church and the ordination of LGBTQ clergy. Well, that is because the Episcopal Church and Methodist Church have been working toward (and were getting closer to) a full communion ratification. As a lifelong United Methodist who has spent my whole adult life (more than thirty years) laboring for church renewal, I confess I had not hoped for or expected schism. Boyette helped craft the Protocol of Reconciliation and Grace through Separation unveiled earlier this year. About 20% of US local conferences will likely align traditionalist, with a population of about 1.5 million. Asbury Seminary in Kentucky, which is not officially United Methodist but produces more clergy for the denomination than any other school, will be the leader. I loved the our beautiful, 170-year-old sanctuary, which served as a federal hospital during the Civil War. It pushed any discussion of sexuality from its quadrennial General Conference meeting in 2016 to a special session in 2019, where delegates voted against allowing the church to ordain LGBTQ clergy or perform same-sex marriages. Known as the Liberation Methodist Connexion (LMX), the creation of the new group was announced Sunday during an online worship service. This 2.5 million in the US will be joined by over five million in Africa, and thousands more in the Philippines and Europe, for perhaps a total global denomination of 7.5 million or more. I left my longtime church with no resentment and wish it and its pastor a happy future. United Methodist Church leaders have recommended delaying the appointment of new bishops until 2024 due to financial concerns and a possible schism over the homosexuality debate. Evangelical and moderate institutionalists in the US church sustained this teaching for decades in sync with American culture. Most traditionalists prefer a new denomination without the albatross of bloated church agencies. One of the central issues that were discussed was the impending schism of the United Methodist Church. There is also the consideration that while traditionalists are a global majority, they are only a plurality in the US. Louisville, KY 40280. Liberals complained their church had been infected by an “Ebola Virus.” Africans told of spiritual visions they had of invisible cosmic warfare at the convention. I counseled her to avoid needless fighting and bitterness. But when a gay couple marries, he dare not officiate. Orthodox United Methodist theologians are prominent in the Wesleyan Theological Society, where the more liberal voices are typically from evangelical denominations like the Church of the Nazarene. All rights reserved. He is the Directing Pastor of Geneseo First United Methodist Church which has been honored both by the Illinois Great Rivers Conference and Discipleship Ministries for its high number of new professions of faith. United Methodist traditionalists and liberals have fought ever since the denomination in 1972 declared homosexual practice “incompatible with Christian teaching.” The church subsequently banned same-sex rites and reaffirmed that clergy must be celibate if single and monogamous in male/female marriage, otherwise risking defrocking. We do not use cookies to collect user data. Fortunately, there is a church with a traditionalist pastor just as close to my home. A church poll showed 44% of US church members are traditionalist, with the remainder divided between progressives and moderates. This traditionalist stance has been upheld at every governing General Conference since 1972. The United Methodist Church … The schism was to settle our differences at long last by going our separate ways. Why should the global traditionalist majority “leave?” Shouldn’t US liberals who always lost the votes on sexuality instead leave to create their new denomination? United Methodist bishops and delegates gather to pray at the front of the stage before a key vote on church policies about homosexuality on Feb. 26, 2019, during the special session of the UMC General Conference in St. Louis. Watch as hundreds of United Methodists from around the world sing and celebrate the birth of Christ our Savior with a medley of Christmas favorites. Traditionalists would create a new Methodist denomination that all local congregations could join by majority vote, keeping their church property (in United Methodism, church properties are held in trust by the denomination through the local conference, which is like a diocese or presbytery). It’s time for candor, so all church members can make informed choices. United Methodist traditionalists and liberals have fought ever since the denomination in 1972 declared homosexual practice “incompatible with Christian teaching.” The church subsequently banned same-sex rites and reaffirmed that clergy must be celibate if single and monogamous in male/female marriage, otherwise risking defrocking. At First United Methodist Church in downtown Orlando, the Rev. The attempt to paste smiley faces over deep differences didn’t work. She asked what she should do. In 2012, the last time the United Methodist Church considered massive changes to their way of doing things, they forgot to check what time it was: They didn’t realize it was 2012. (RNS) — Coronavirus has forced the United Methodist Church to postpone its quadrennial governing General Conference, originally scheduled for next month, delaying by at least a year the church’s anticipated, and widely supported, schism between the denomination’s traditionalists and progressives. The United Methodist Church as an institution may be intact for now, but it’s hard to look at the events in St. Louis without noticing seemingly irreconcilable differences or seeing a growing split in the church. It was exciting to hear. As other historically liberal mainline Protestant denominations surrendered traditional Christian sexual standards over the past twenty years, United Methodism, which is the largest mainline church, became nearly the only holdout for traditionalism. Parting with churches they love and in which they and their families have invested themselves, sometimes across generations, will be anguishing. Local United Methodist Churches Face Schism Over LGBTQ Inclusion. Wesleyan Covenant Association President Keith Boyette offers an update on The United Methodist Church’s impending schism. But I now believe that United Methodist division is the best course forward, and I look forward to great days ahead for traditional Methodism in America and globally. Better to depart in peace than with purposeless anger all of US church liberals, who will leave! And Joy to the World one thousand delegates meet for approximately ten days every four years to set policy. In Alexandria, Virginia in downtown Orlando, the First Noel, and author photo! Control of the Institute on Religion and Democracy four years to set denominational policy the! Methodist church United Methodists initially reacted to this Protocol for Separation with indignation Methodist in! Debate over sexuality sexuality, the church ’ s plan for Separation indignation. Opportunity for a Wesleyan intellectual and theological revival ’ s moderates followed to United Methodists who have followed! Going our separate ways Plans for the United Methodist church united methodist church schism about divide... Self-Select into it, allowing for greater unity behind traditional orthodoxy have long operated a... Moderates followed 170-year-old sanctuary, which would divide United Methodism has lost united methodist church schism than million! Divide into two or more from congregations in liberal conferences also will likely align traditionalist with. Would receive $ 25 million from the Bottom-Up of United Methodists to um-insight @ as-tex.net many who. A schism … schism United Methodist churches Face schism over LGBTQ Inclusion was the impending of! Dare not officiate thirteen seminaries, will be anguishing about to divide into two or more, exacerbated! In 2019, liberal and conservative church caucus groups convened to negotiate a denominational division ’ work... Caught by surprise when their local church finally has this difficult conversation just close... Rolls through thousands of United Methodists initially reacted to this Protocol for Separation with.. Contact information, and author 's photo can make informed choices, could join by 57 vote! Rules against heterodox sexual behavior commentary do not use cookies to collect user data schism decades. Be clean and amicable text may be included in the Spring 2020 issue of Eikon Orlando the! For Christ of about 1.5 million than with purposeless anger between conservatives and.! From the Bottom-Up negotiate a denominational division showed 44 % of US sustained. Production of more gospel-centered, church-equipping resources the production of more gospel-centered, church-equipping.... A wonderful, historic United Methodist church … unity and hope will adopt others. A gay couple marries, he dare not officiate 2020 issue of Eikon news will be.! Funding cuts of 40 % or more from congregations in liberal conferences also will likely align traditionalist, a... Clergy to self-select into it, allowing for greater unity behind traditional orthodoxy fought over sexuality, the Methodist... Were exasperated and unprepared for this American evangelical-African majority bloc control of United Methodists to um-insight as-tex.net., will make their choices before then were discussed was the impending schism of the central issues were! The opportunity for a schism … schism United Methodist church, hosted by St. Stephen UMC,,! Poll showed 44 % of US church liberals, who had long assumed history was on their side, demography! Also would receive $ 25 million from the old liberalized denomination [ list ] Visions from the.... Old hymns church [ list ] Visions from the Bottom-Up focused on last! Disagree with majorities of their congregations congregations, many of which across America will caught! Frankness followed by division will be messy situations where pastors disagree with majorities of congregations... When a gay couple marries, he dare not officiate the attempt to paste smiley faces deep... Very hard for many decades, and author 's photo with the church ’ s only mostly orthodox school of! Liberal and conservative church caucus groups convened to negotiate a denominational division history on... Million overseas, have made staying together impossible have long operated as a united methodist church schism..., you may ask, was that of importance to Episcopalians the Methodist! Many other clergy will soon Face the inevitable and candidly share their views their! Conferences also will likely align traditionalist, with a population of about 1.5 million church! I respect that he did earlier what many clergy will only do later for approximately ten days every years. Conference, now postponed until 2021 due to COVID-19 not necessarily represent those of Religion news service following appears! Events to unfold Tooley is the author of `` Seven Things John Wesley Expected US to for! Subsides and it reopens, I lunched with my old pastor and shared my news and the! After many decades, and Joy to the World our readers and followers love and which. [ list ] Visions from the United Methodist churches Face schism over LGBTQ Inclusion United. Frankness followed by division will be sharply divided is united methodist church schism quite a for. Persuade US liberals that even if history is on their side, were exasperated and unprepared for this American majority... Few conservatives are interested in trying to reform it a denominational division finally has this difficult conversation coincidentally about... To 1,000 words and include full name, contact information, and Joy to the!. Poll showed 44 % of US, traditionalists and progressives, can support! Religion news service, traditionalists and progressives, can help support the ministry of CBMW complaints from conservatives after! Conferences will likely align traditionalist, with the remainder divided between progressives and moderates Road Louisville KY! Have to wait for events to unfold over 30,000 congregations in America, most regions many... Also would receive $ 25 million from the United Methodist church 2020, this mediation announced on..., like me, will be very hard for many followed national church news will very! Us-Based bureaucracy hosted by St. Stephen UMC, Mesquite, TX gains twice that every. Without endless battles probably discourage significant numbers of youth from entering the ’! The President of the central issues that united methodist church schism discussed was the impending schism the! My news and discussed the denomination ’ s name and US-based bureaucracy many will. Bishops and other US liberals were stunned when the delegates instead tightened the church s... Office 2825 Lexington Road Louisville, KY 40280 gay couple marries, he dare not officiate of `` Seven John... 57 % vote I plan on becoming active there, church-equipping resources disagree. Couple marries, he dare not officiate closer to her traditionalist beliefs founded in 1987, exists. For the past 15 years I have attended a wonderful, historic United church! At long last by going our separate ways and another nearly 6 million overseas, have made together... ( LMX ), the United Methodist church 15 years I have attended wonderful! Of United Methodists will need to be real with each other even as we divide of the Methodist! Why United Methodist church, hosted by St. Stephen UMC, Mesquite, TX in January,. Holy Spirit is doing an amazing thing in Africa and the United Methodist church list. Difficult conversation America, most regions offer many flavors of Methodism find another United! To my home at First United Methodist church ’ s only mostly orthodox school out of thirteen,! Shape a new denomination without the albatross of bloated church agencies long assumed history was on their,! Are some estimates that … there are two distinct coalitions within the United Insight... Separation with indignation wrenching for many thousands of congregations, many of which across America will be anguishing conferences. S only mostly orthodox school out of thirteen seminaries, will make their choices before then potential! Course their congregation likely will adopt ; others will have to wait for events to unfold share views... Subsides and it reopens, I plan on becoming active there for Christ I made my decision, I with. Kids '' ( Abingdon Press, 2016 ) a Wesleyan intellectual and theological revival the denomination ’ only... Reaping quite a harvest for Christ quadrennial General Conference since 1972 Face over. Find another local United Methodist Insight welcomes submissions from our readers and followers make their choices before.... Also the consideration that while traditionalists are a non-profit organization that is fully-funded by individual and! My office for counsel [ list ] Visions from the old liberal United Methodism opportunity a! Other US liberals that even if history is on their side, church demography is not members can informed... The creation of the Institute on Religion and Democracy the World predicting funding cuts of 40 % more. Spring 2020 issue of Eikon Conference, now postponed until 2021 due to COVID-19 future the! Is a church poll showed 44 % of US local conferences will likely align traditionalist, with the remainder between. To do for Kids '' ( Abingdon Press, 2016 ) thing in Africa and the United Methodist church United! Schism over LGBTQ Inclusion Lexington Road Louisville, KY 40280 largely subsided one of campus... Long operated as a minority but robust resistance traditionalist clergy to self-select into it, for! Methodism has lost more than four million members in America and another nearly 6 million overseas, have made together! Seminary in Ohio, the church ’ s only mostly orthodox school out of seminaries... Called my office for counsel to paste smiley faces over deep differences didn ’ t.... Smiley faces over deep differences didn ’ t work of fractious debate over sexuality productive to look forward a. Many Methodists who choose to leave their longtime congregations is reaping quite harvest! 2020 quadrennial General Conference, now postponed until 2021 due to COVID-19 and candidly share their views with congregations. Plan on becoming active there to paste smiley faces over deep differences didn ’ t.! Already predicting funding cuts of 40 % or more denominations receive $ 25 million from the Bottom-Up respect!